FILM: A Beautiful Day In The Neighborhood

In the film A Beautiful Day In The Neighborhood, we are shown the extraordinary nature of Mister Rogers through a perfect foil: a cynical, hard-boiled reporter from Esquire who is sent to profile him and whose iconoclastic instincts lead him to look for a dark underbelly or some hint of dirt. Instead, he learns that the earnestness of Fred Rogers is actually earnest, as Rogers befriends the reporter and helps him heal some long-broken-and-buried parts of his own life. Tom Hanks is uncanny in his portrayal of the TV icon, and director Marielle Heller keeps the film honest, avoiding the clear pitfalls of such material that could have easily careened into maudlin Hallmark territory. When the reporter, Lloyd Vogel, finally completes his assignment, his wife’s reaction on reading it is, “this is great, although it’s more about you than about him.” Which is certainly true, and this film is more about Lloyd Vogel’s journey (note that Tom Hanks is nominated for best supporting actor), perhaps the best way to understand Mr. Rogers is in his interaction with and impact on others. We get little glimpses into the life of Fred Rogers – his daily routines of swimming and praying and playing the piano. His wife Joanne assures Lloyd that he is not a saint, he has a temper at times, and he works very hard to be the person that he is. But aside from that, he remains an enigma even at the end of the film, and he is rather saint-like. One rather telling moment in one of their early interviews, Vogel asks Rogers to make a distinction between Fred Rogers the real person and “Mister Rogers” the character, and Rogers is genuinely baffled by the concept – he is truly just being himself. And Rogers is one of those rare people for whom the most important person in the world at any given moment is the person right in front of them in that moment, a focus that creates a compelling rapport. He’s also thoughtfully slow and comfortable with uncomfortable silences, a trait that draws people out. But most of all, he was supremely compassionate and empathetic. He may not have been a saint, but he’s about as close as they come.